• Q and A

    Questions and Answers from the Risale-i Nur Collection
  • 1

Does God Cancel His Decree?

(Divine Destiny and Decree, and Divine Grace)


Divine Decree means carrying out Destiny’s decisions or judgments. It includes our actions and God’s creation of them at the same time, for God allows us to do what we will to do by bringing it into existence. The Arabic word translated here as “Divine Grace” is ‘ata, which means giving freely or liberality.

God has two main records or registers: the Supreme Preserved Tablet (corresponding to Destiny or Divine Knowledge) and the Manifest Record (corresponding to the reality of time). The Supreme Preserved Tablet never changes, since God also has absolutely unrestricted Will and is therefore not restricted by the Destiny He established for His creatures. However, He may change what He records in the Manifest Book: God effaces whatever He wills and confirms whatever He wills, with Him is the Mother of the Book (13:39).

This is a subtle matter, one difficult to understand. Although we cannot fully understand the reality of this effacement and confirmation, we frequently witness it in our lives. For example, one day we leave home with the intention of going to a place where sins are freely committed. However, out of His mercy and favor, God arranges for us to meet some good friends who persuade us to go to a good place. Likewise, we commit sins too freely and are therefore subject to misfortune. But instead of dealing with us from His Justice, God, out of His grace, treats us with utmost grace and pardons us, thereby saving us from misfortune.

Divine Grace exists so that we will not despair of being forgiven, so that we may turn to Him despite the enormity of our sins, and so that we should not see ourselves as absolutely bound by the consequences that Divine Destiny and Decree establishes for our deeds. This is made explicit in the following verses:

Whatever misfortune befalls you, is for what your own hands have earned, and for many (of them) He grants forgiveness. (42:30)

If God were to punish men for their wrongdoing, He would not leave on the Earth a single living creature; but He reprieves them to an appointed term. (16:61)

Relate [to them from Me): “O My slaves who have transgressed against their selves! Do not despair of God’s mercy! Surely God forgives all sins; for He is the All-Forgiving, the Most Compassionate. (39:53)

Divine grace or liberality manifests itself more clearly in human history. Being responsible and accountable for their acts, people direct their own history. Such historical philosophies as historicism are far from the truth, for there is no determining the reality of history or historical events.

Many historical people, such as those ‘Ad, Thamud, and Pharaoh’s people deserved to perish because of their dissolute lifestyles, injustices, and atrocities. And so God eradicated them. However, Prophet Jonah’s people, upon him be peace, turned to God with utmost sincerity and deep repentance, and reformed themselves morally after they saw signs of impending destruction. As a result, God spared them the penalty of disgrace in the life of this world, and gave them comfort for a while (10:98). Emphasizing this point, God’s Messenger, upon him be peace and blessings, said: Fear does not prevent misfortunes, but prayer and charity prevent them.

Therefore, believers should never cease praying and giving charity. When they feel misfortune coming, they should immediately turn to God in prayer, repent, give charity to the poor, or perform some service for Islam.


This article has been adapted from Risale- i Nur Collection.